How This World-Class Design Became a Great Success Story
Place de la République, by Trévelo & Viger-Kohler , in Paris, France.
Most people know that Paris is often called “The City of Love”. Fewer have heard that Paris is also known as “The City of Light”. The first alias needs no explanation; the second one certainly does. Paris has been called “The City of Light” because of its leading role in the Age of Enlightenment, but also because France’s capital was one of the first European cities to adopt gas street lighting.
Another interesting fact about the city is that — unlike the majority of other world capitals — Paris has never been destroyed by war or catastrophe. And despite modernizing the urban scape, architecture, and infrastructure, the city zealously guards its earliest historical tracks on its street map.
IN THIS ARTICLE, we will discuss the redevelopment of one of the most key and special places in the city – the 3.8-hectare grand Place de la République square. If you are curious to find out how The City of Light has once again manifested its classy attitude toward architecture, join us now; you will be fascinated at the end.
Place de la République: Before and After
Before the design intervention of the French architecture and urbanism agency TVK, Place de la République had a different organization. The square was comprised of two gardens and a busy roundabout in between, with the statue of the Republic soaring above the traffic flow.
Because the square holds a very significant location in the city due to the intersection of three Parisian districts and seven major arteries, the road traffic had often been heavy and blocked. The team of TVK came up with a design solution aiming to transfigure Place de la République into the largest pedestrian area to represent one of the most appreciable 21st century monuments in Paris.
Green Light to Pedestrians
To create a vast concourse ready to accommodate a great stream of people, the designers had no other choice but to abandon the circle model of traffic. Thus, an undisturbed and bracingly calming two-hectare space was defined – free of vehicles and full of trees and people.
According to the architects: “We are proposing to create a vast public space reserved for pedestrians and cyclists, and to create a connection to the square at the northeast border. In order to create this link, it is necessary to cut the circulation of traffic on the street Faubourg du Temple at its intersection with the street Yves Toudic, and to extend the public space up to this point. In this way, the future Place de la République would be a large free space of two hectares, opening onto the main boulevards.”
Did the city of Paris need such a large public plaza? What does the renovated square offer?
One Axis, Multiple Uses
Besides shaping a more contemporary appearance, the reconstructed landscape provides a spirited urban place that welcomes versatile uses. The main axis outlining the composition is formed by four elements — the statue of Marianne, the reflective pool, the pavilion, and the tree rows. These four components together and separately add a sense of representativeness, accompanied by an ambiance of vivacity and aspiration.
CONNECTED DIRECTLY TO THE BUILDINGS’ facades on one of its sides, the plaza seizes people right from the moment they step onto the paving slabs. A visitor can go to the pavilion and grab a cup of coffee, then sit for a while to contemplate the children playing in the reflective pool, or walk around the statue and draw a breath of its grandeur. The two terraces are another opportunity for recreation or a friendly conversation shared in the pleasant atmosphere of the naturally raised platforms.
Why Asymmetrical Design?
Place de la République’s transformation continues with the induction of two-fold dissymmetry along the long axis, adding a functional and environmental value to the project. The asymmetrical composition not only incorporates the large pedestrian square into the surrounding environment, but also considers the climate characteristics of the place.
This type of tree arrangement reinforces the vital presence of greenery while letting sunbeams reach the alleys and warm winds penetrate and refresh the air. Respectively, in winter, the trees block the cold winds.
In addition, the new motor traffic organization passes along the southern edge and onto only two smaller sides of the square, instead of marking the center of the plaza.
Unified in Sweet Harmony
Our before-and-after comparison moves on to reach the issue of how the design elements correspond to one another. It is important to mention that Place de la République is situated above telecom tunnels, sewers, and five metro lines, which means the esplanade also serves as a roof. There is an almost imperceptible 1 percent inclination of the terrain, which elegantly slopes toward the two buildings to the north and continues to the shared traffic area of pedestrians, buses, cycles, and taxis. Thus, excellent accessibility and continuity are ensured.
Materials Choices in the Design
The impression of unification appears on the surface of the esplanade, as well. The mixture of light and dark paving slabs covers both the open and shady areas. Varying in size and hues, the prefabricated, durable concrete slabs “play” with the surrounding pavement while complementing and enriching it. The only edifice popping out from the surface is the pavilion, which houses a “World & Media”-themed café, eager to cooperate with social and cultural initiatives.
Resonant Architecture and Landscaping
The pavilion has a subtle and minimalistic design, in accordance with the holistic, representative appearance of the square. Facing the statue of the Republic and the reflective pool, the café’s walls are transparent so that they do not obscure the vista.
See More Great Projects From Paris, France:
- Is The André Citroën Park Really One of The Worst Parks in Paris?
- Incredible Double Footbridge in Paris
- Is France Leading the Game in Sustainable Urban Planning?
The Use of Water in The Design
Now that we have mentioned the reflective pool, it’s necessary to highlight the water features and their meaning for the plaza. Besides the reflective pool, water takes form in a circular basin surrounding the monument. Water in the square functions aesthetically, socially, culturally, and ecologically – a plethora of virtues needed for an up-to-date urban design.
The Careful Selection of Vegetation
Last but not least, we focus on the vegetation — more than 150 plane and honey locust trees. The strict tree rows once again underline the dignified appearance and character of Place de la République.
Place de la République in Numbers
• Square size — 280m x 120m
• Pedestrian area – 2 ha
• Pedestrian-traffic proportion before – 1:2
• Pedestrian-traffic proportion now – 2:1
• Pavilion area — 162m²
• Reflecting pool — 276m²
• Statue basin – 3m wide
• Lighting features – 34
• Historic candelabra – 19
• Wooden benches – 24
• Concrete slabs – 3 sizes, 12 and 14cm thick
• Plane trees – 134
• Honey locust trees – 18
• Wild cherry – 1
• Trees before the redevelopment – 225
• Trees after the renovation – 251
Was TVK’s Redevelopment the Best Possible Design Solution?
Having gone through the profound analysis of Place de la République’s new design, a few questions come up. People’s opinions are controversial, and some of them don’t approve of the removal of the green lawns and the fountains. It is not certain if the traffic has been optimized since the roundabout was removed, either.
However, the benefits from the reconstruction have an incalculable value. The fact that people can now reach the Statue of the République freely and literally touch the history of France is sufficient on its own. People need to be connected to their history, to their city, and to each other. And that’s exactly what the new Place de la République offers.
What is your opinion? Was TVK’s design solution appropriate? If not, what are your arguments?
Full Project Credits For Place de la République
Project Name: Place de la République
Location: Paris, France
Architects: TVK / Trévelo & Viger-Kohler
Landscaping: Martha Schwartz and AREAL
Client: City of Paris, Highways Department (Direction de la Voierie et Déplacements)
Area: 3.8 hectares + 162 square meters
Technical Consultants: ATEC
Traffic and Movement Consultants: CITEC
Fountain Consultants: JML Consultants
Lighting Design: AIK – Yann Kersale
Environmental Consultants: Transsolar
Dialogue and Consulting: Ville Ouverte
Team Square: TVK, Areal, Martha Schwartz, Atec, JML, Citec, Transsolar, Ville Ouverte, AIK, Segic
Team Pavilion: TVK, ARC, Atec, Transsolar, NP2F
Project Year: 2011
Construction Date: 2013
- Urban Design by Alex Krieger
- The Urban Design Handbook: Techniques and Working Methods (Second Edition) by Urban Design Associates
Article by Velislava Valcheva
Latest posts by Velislava Valcheva, Writer of the Year 2015/16 (see all)
- Sätra Centre: How a Public Square Turned into a Cozy Living Room - November 24, 2015
- 7 Common Mistakes People Make When Selecting Trees and How to Avoid Them - November 19, 2015
- The Play Structure That Travels in Space and Time - November 17, 2015
Explore Landscape Architects Network
Blocs 77 | How to Create a Landscape Design Without a Landscape
Article by Eleni Tsirintani - A review of the Blocs 77 Condominium project, designed by ...read more
How The Drawers House Uses the Landscape to Control the Climate
Article by Maria Giovanna Drago - A review of The Drawers House by MIA Design ...read more
Why Sydney Needs Barangaroo Reserve
Article by Irene Crowo Nielsen - Barangaroo Reserve by Peter Walker and Partners Landscape Architecture (PWP), ...read more
How to Revitalize a Park Design in 5 Steps
Article by Maria Giovanna Drago - A review of the park design at Drapers Field ...read more
Green Arena Shows us How to Set the Stage for a Diverse Landscape
Article by Kurt Longland - A review of Green Arena, by Stradivarie Associated Architect, in ...read more
LAN’s Top Announcements 2016/17
A round-up of Landscape Architects Network’s 2016/17 announcements. 2016 was a year filled with experimentation (launch ...read more
Top 10 Landscape Architecture Projects 2016
The official Landscape Architects Network choices are here for our top 10 landscape architecture projects 2016. ...read more
Stunning Garden Design Brings Inspiration and Italian Charm
Article by Eni Çeka - A project review of the Villa in Monte Argentario, by ...read more
Why Working with the Locals is the Best Way to Revitalize a Neighborhood
Article by Kamil Rawski – Malgrat de Mar by Territori24, in Malgrat de Mar, Spain, ...read more